When it comes to selecting a breast pump, it’s crucial to consider all the factors to ensure you’re making the best choice for your personal circumstances.
In this article, we’re going to compare two of the most popular breast pumps in Australia: the Spectra S2+ and the Tommee Tippee Electric Breast Pump Gen 2.
We’ll delve into their key similarities, significant differences, and discuss some general considerations when choosing a breast pump. Our goal is to equip you with the information you need to make an informed decision.
Editors note: While the S2+ is a high-quality pump, before reading this comparison, we recommend you check out Spectra’s new Dual S breast pump, which is their latest hospital-grade pump and features a number of benefits over the S2+.
Spectra S2+ vs Tommee Tippee Electric Breast Pump Gen 2: Key Similarities
Quiet Operation
Both the Spectra S2+ and the Tommee Tippee Electric Breast Pump Gen 2 are designed to operate quietly.
This feature is particularly useful for mothers who wish to pump discreetly in various settings, whether that be at work, at home, or in public spaces.
Hygienic Closed System
A closed system in a breast pump ensures that milk doesn’t come into contact with the motor or tubing, reducing the risk of contamination.
Both the Spectra S2+ and the Tommee Tippee Gen 2 offer this hygienic design feature, demonstrating a commitment to the safety and health of both mother and baby.
Adjustable Programs
Both pumps provide adjustable programs, allowing mothers to customize their pumping experience to their comfort and needs.
Night Light and Timer
The Spectra S2+ and the Tommee Tippee Gen 2 are equipped with a night light and a timer.
These features are particularly beneficial for night-time pumping, as they allow mothers to see what they’re doing and keep track of pumping duration without needing to switch on bright overhead lights.
Editor’s note: The Spectra S2+ comes with a size 24mm breast shield only. We recommend you order replacement shields in your correct size when you purchase your pump.
Spectra S2+ vs Tommee Tippee Electric Breast Pump Gen 2: Key Differences
Price
At the time of writing, the Spectra breast pump is priced at AUD $299.00. The Tommee Tippee is generally available for less than half this price, making it a much more affordable option.
Grade
The Spectra S2+ is classified as a hospital-grade breast pump, while the Tommee Tippee Gen 2 is designed for personal use.
Hospital-grade pumps are known for their durability, robustness, and higher suction capabilities, making them a popular choice for mothers who need to pump frequently.
Weight
The Spectra S2+ weighs 2 kg, which is over double the weight of the Tommee Tippee Gen 2, which weighs in at just 0.9 kg.
This factor could be important for mothers who require a lightweight and portable pump.
Power Source
The Spectra S2+ is mains-powered only, meaning it needs to be plugged in to operate. On the other hand, the Tommee Tippee Gen 2 features a built-in rechargeable battery, offering more flexibility and portability.
LCD Display
Unlike the Spectra S2+, the Tommee Tippee Gen 2 features an LCD display. This could make it easier for mothers to monitor and adjust their pumping settings.
What to Consider When Choosing a Breast Pump
When choosing a breast pump, there are several key factors to consider, including:
Frequency of Use: If you’re planning on pumping regularly, a more robust, hospital-grade pump might be a more suitable choice.
Portability: If you’ll be pumping on the go, a lightweight pump with a rechargeable battery will likely be your best bet.
Price: The cost of the breast pump is an essential factor to take into account. A more affordable pump may seem like the best choice, but it’s important to ensure it also meets your other requirements.
Comfort and Ease of Use: Every woman’s body is unique, and what works for one might not work for another. Features such as adjustable settings can provide a more personalized, comfortable experience. Additionally, consider the pump’s user interface and whether it’s easy to understand and operate.
Hygiene: A closed system pump, like the Spectra S2+ and the Tommee Tippee Gen 2, can help to reduce the risk of contamination, ensuring the health and safety of you and your baby.
Additional Features: Think about any extra features you may value, such as a timer or night light for night-time pumping, or an LCD display for monitoring and adjusting settings.
Conclusion
Choosing a breast pump is an important decision that can significantly impact your breastfeeding journey. Whether you prefer the hospital-grade Spectra S2+ or the lighter and more portable Tommee Tippee Gen 2 will depend on your personal circumstances and needs.
While the Spectra S2+ offers a robust pumping experience, it comes with a higher price tag and requires a power source. The Tommee Tippee Gen 2, on the other hand, is more affordable, portable, and includes a handy LCD display.
Weighing the similarities and differences, as well as considering your individual needs, will ensure that you find the pump that best suits your lifestyle. After all, the ultimate goal is to make your breastfeeding experience as comfortable and efficient as possible. Your satisfaction and the health of your baby are of paramount importance.
We hope this comparison has given you a clearer picture and will guide you in making an informed decision. Happy breastfeeding!
